<address id="lxrbh"></address>
      <em id="lxrbh"><span id="lxrbh"></span></em>

      ScienceDaily
      Your source for the latest research news
      Follow Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Subscribe RSS Feeds Newsletters
      New:
      • New Physics and the Early Universe
      • How SARS-CoV-2 Rapidly Damages Human Lung Cells
      • Greenland Ice Sheet Faces Irreversible Melting
      • Early Changes in Alzheimer’s Before Symptoms
      • Fingerprints Strengthen Human Touch
      • Is It Better to Give Than Receive?
      • New Hubble Data Explains Missing Dark Matter
      • What Triggers Leaf Die-Off in Autumn?
      • Alligators Can Regrow Their Tails Too
      • Two Liquid States of Water Exist
      advertisement
      Follow all of ScienceDaily's latest research news and top science headlines!
      Science News
      from research organizations

      1

      2

      Congress must clarify limits of gene-editing technologies

      Date:
      October 21, 2020
      Source:
      University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, News Bureau
      Summary:
      How the next Congress decides to handle the issue editing human sperm and eggs will affect the science, ethics and financing of genomic editing for decades to come, said a law professor who studies the ethical and policy implications of advanced biotechnologies.
      Share:
      FULL STORY

      Genome editing of human embryos represents one of the most contentious potential scientific applications today. But what if geneticists could sidestep the controversy by editing sperm and eggs instead?

      advertisement

      According to a new paper co-written by a University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign legal expert who studies the ethical and policy implications of advanced biotechnologies, how the next Congress decides to handle the issue will affect the science, ethics and financing of genome editing for decades to come.

      Although there are a number of statutes and federal appropriation riders that take as their bioethical center the human embryo, none exist that govern the editing of "gametes" -- that is, sperm and eggs, said Jacob S. Sherkow, a professor of law at Illinois.

      "The current federal funding ban is predicated on a concept of bioethics that focuses on the embryo, and that's because there's widespread recognition in U.S. society that embryos have a certain moral salience that other biological components don't," he said. "But with advances in biotechnology, you can get around that. You can sidestep editing embryos by editing sperm and eggs, instead.

      "Regardless of how one thinks about whether embryos should get special bioethical status in this context, you have to understand that the same technology can now be used on sperm and eggs. So federal funding bans on genetically editing embryos with technologies such as CRISPR may not extend to future generations of the technology -- and those future generations are coming quickly."

      In the paper, Sherkow and co-authors Eli Y. Adashi of Brown University and I. Glenn Cohen of Harvard Law School discuss how the editing of sperm and eggs differs from embryos from a bioethical and U.S. legal perspective.

      advertisement

      "This is particularly timely for two reasons," he said. "One, genome-editing technology is getting more effective, cheaper and safer to use every day; and two, this is an election year. We're going to seat a new Congress in January, and whether to continue down this path is something that the new Congress is going to have to decide."

      The main statute that prohibits the clinical use of heritable genomic editing is an annually renewed Congressional appropriations rider first put into law in 2015.

      According to Sherkow and his colleagues, the rider was initially dropped into an appropriations bill with little discussion. The language was briefly removed last year, prompting a debate about whether it applied to certain mitochondrial-replacement therapies and ought to be reinserted.

      "The debate was firmly centered on the editing of embryos, but no legislator considered whether the language also applied to the editing of sperm and eggs," Sherkow said. "And there are strong arguments to be made that the plain text of the rider does not apply to sperm and eggs."

      If the appropriations rider doesn't apply to editing sperm and eggs, then those who believe that such editing is just as problematic as editing embryos "should seek to alter the rider to make it apply to sperm and egg editing, as well," Sherkow said.

      advertisement

      "Some of the ethical concerns raised about editing embryos are applicable to editing sperm and eggs while others are not," he said. "Objections to embryonic gene editing due to the need to destroy human embryos in research and clinical applications are quite different for sperm and eggs."

      Those who have opposed the destruction of embryos, including members of some religious communities, haven't raised similar objections to sperm and egg editing, Sherkow said.

      "Proponents of embryonic personhood claims emphasize that the genetic code of the early embryo is set at the time when sperm and egg form a zygote. But sperm and egg editing occurs before that moment, toppling the claim that editing gametes alters 'a person,' and is really more analogous to selecting a sperm or egg donor."

      At the same time, policymakers should be heartened by the notion that "we don't necessarily have to stop research on these technologies because now we have the ability to do it in gametes as opposed to embryos," said Sherkow, who also is an affiliate of the Carl R. Woese Institute for Genomic Biology.

      "The new Congress that's seated in January should pay attention to the development of genome-editing technologies like these, and should be more attuned to the extent of what limits it wants to put on research, given that such research can proceed without some of the moral trappings that have jammed prior Congresses," he said. "For those who think that there are important differences between embryos and gametes, this may offer an opportunity to develop a different regulated pathway for sperm and egg editing."

      The paper was published in the Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics.

      make a difference: sponsored opportunity

      Story Source:

      Materials provided by University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, News Bureau. Original written by Phil Ciciora. Note: Content may be edited for style and length.


      Journal Reference:

      1. I. Glenn Cohen, Jacob S. Sherkow, Eli Y. Adashi. Gene Editing Sperm and Eggs (not Embryos): Does it Make a Legal or Ethical Difference? The Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics, 2020; 48 (3): 619 DOI: 10.1177/1073110520958891

      Cite This Page:

      • MLA
      • APA
      • Chicago
      University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, News Bureau. "Congress must clarify limits of gene-editing technologies." ScienceDaily. ScienceDaily, 21 October 2020. <www.theclynefaction.com/releases/2020/10/201021111558.htm>.
      University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, News Bureau. (2020, October 21). Congress must clarify limits of gene-editing technologies. ScienceDaily. Retrieved December 3, 2020 from www.theclynefaction.com/releases/2020/10/201021111558.htm
      University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, News Bureau. "Congress must clarify limits of gene-editing technologies." ScienceDaily. www.theclynefaction.com/releases/2020/10/201021111558.htm (accessed December 3, 2020).

      • RELATED TOPICS
        • Health & Medicine
          • Pregnancy and Childbirth
          • Fertility
          • Stem Cells
        • Matter & Energy
          • Energy Policy
          • Biometric
          • Vehicles
        • Science & Society
          • Bioethics
          • Ethics
          • STEM Education
      advertisement

      • RELATED TERMS
        • Bioethics
        • Funding policies for science
        • Industrial relations
        • Justice
        • Memory
        • Sex education
        • Judicial power
        • Cervical cancer

      1

      2

      3

      4

      5
      RELATED STORIES

      Heritable Genome Editing: Action Needed to Secure Responsible Way Forward
      July 16, 2018 — An independent inquiry has concluded that editing the DNA of a human embryo, sperm, or egg to influence the characteristics of a future person ('heritable genome editing') could be morally ...
      Cautious but Proactive Approach to Gene Editing Urged by Multiple Organizations
      Aug. 3, 2017 — An international group of 11 organizations with genetics expertise has issued a policy statement on germline genome editing in humans, which recommends against genome editing that culminates in human ...
      Genome Editing in Clinical Genetics: Points to Consider
      Jan. 27, 2017 — Genome editing, including CRISPR/Cas9, is a new and notable technology that enables geneticists and researchers to edit parts of the human genome. The American College of Medical Genetics and ...
      Ethical Challenges of Genome Editing
      Oct. 3, 2016 — Preventing the transmission of inherited genetic diseases, and increasing food production rates in farmed animals are two potential applications of genome editing technologies that require urgent ...
      FROM AROUND THE WEB

      ScienceDaily shares links with sites in the TrendMD network and earns revenue from third-party advertisers, where indicated.
        Print   Email   Share

      advertisement

      1

      2

      3

      4

      5
      Most Popular
      this week

      HEALTH & MEDICINE
      The Six Strains of SARS-CoV-2
      Glucosamine May Reduce Overall Death Rates as Effectively as Regular Exercise, Study Suggests
      (c) (c) Photocreo Bednarek / AdobeResearchers Examine Which Approaches Are Most Effective at Reducing COVID-19 Spread
      MIND & BRAIN
      (c) (c) pelooyen / AdobeZebra Finches Amazing at Unmasking the Bird Behind the Song
      (c) (c) whitehoune / AdobeFrom the Inside Out: How the Brain Forms Sensory Memories
      (c) (c) oatawa / AdobeHealthy Sleep Habits Help Lower Risk of Heart Failure
      LIVING & WELL
      Boy or Girl? It's in the Father's Genes
      Aim to Exceed Weekly Recommended Physical Activity Level to Offset Health Harms of Prolonged Sitting
      Everyday Activities Enhance Personal Well-Being
      advertisement

      Strange & Offbeat
       

      HEALTH & MEDICINE
      Biofriendly Protocells Pump Up Blood Vessels
      Researchers Identify Features That Could Make Someone a Virus Super-Spreader
      New Effective and Safe Antifungal Isolated from Sea Squirt Microbiome
      MIND & BRAIN
      (c) (c) pelooyen / AdobeZebra Finches Amazing at Unmasking the Bird Behind the Song
      A Malformation Illustrates the Incredible Plasticity of the Brain
      Water Fleas on 'Happy Pills' Have More Offspring
      LIVING & WELL
      Key Advance for Printing Circuitry on Wearable Fabrics
      Luminescent Wood Could Light Up Homes of the Future
      Research Lays Groundwork for Ultra-Thin, Energy Efficient Photodetector on Glass
      SD
      • SD
        • Home Page
        • Top Science News
        • Latest News
      • Home
        • Home Page
        • Top Science News
        • Latest News
      • Health
        • View all the latest top news in the health sciences,
          or browse the topics below:
          Health & Medicine
          • Allergy
          • Alternative Medicine
          • Birth Control
          • Cancer
          • Diabetes
          • Diseases
          • Heart Disease
          • HIV and AIDS
          • Obesity
          • Stem Cells
          • ... more topics
          Mind & Brain
          • ADD and ADHD
          • Addiction
          • Alzheimer's
          • Autism
          • Depression
          • Headaches
          • Intelligence
          • Psychology
          • Relationships
          • Schizophrenia
          • ... more topics
          Living Well
          • Parenting
          • Pregnancy
          • Sexual Health
          • Skin Care
          • Men's Health
          • Women's Health
          • Nutrition
          • Diet and Weight Loss
          • Fitness
          • Healthy Aging
          • ... more topics
      • Tech
        • View all the latest top news in the physical sciences & technology,
          or browse the topics below:
          Matter & Energy
          • Aviation
          • Chemistry
          • Electronics
          • Fossil Fuels
          • Nanotechnology
          • Physics
          • Quantum Physics
          • Solar Energy
          • Technology
          • Wind Energy
          • ... more topics
          Space & Time
          • Astronomy
          • Black Holes
          • Dark Matter
          • Extrasolar Planets
          • Mars
          • Moon
          • Solar System
          • Space Telescopes
          • Stars
          • Sun
          • ... more topics
          Computers & Math
          • Artificial Intelligence
          • Communications
          • Computer Science
          • Hacking
          • Mathematics
          • Quantum Computers
          • Robotics
          • Software
          • Video Games
          • Virtual Reality
          • ... more topics
      • Enviro
        • View all the latest top news in the environmental sciences,
          or browse the topics below:
          Plants & Animals
          • Agriculture and Food
          • Animals
          • Biology
          • Biotechnology
          • Endangered Animals
          • Extinction
          • Genetically Modified
          • Microbes and More
          • New Species
          • Zoology
          • ... more topics
          Earth & Climate
          • Climate
          • Earthquakes
          • Environment
          • Geography
          • Geology
          • Global Warming
          • Hurricanes
          • Ozone Holes
          • Pollution
          • Weather
          • ... more topics
          Fossils & Ruins
          • Ancient Civilizations
          • Anthropology
          • Archaeology
          • Dinosaurs
          • Early Humans
          • Early Mammals
          • Evolution
          • Lost Treasures
          • Origin of Life
          • Paleontology
          • ... more topics
      • Society
        • View all the latest top news in the social sciences & education,
          or browse the topics below:
          Science & Society
          • Arts & Culture
          • Consumerism
          • Economics
          • Political Science
          • Privacy Issues
          • Public Health
          • Racial Disparity
          • Religion
          • Sports
          • World Development
          • ... more topics
          Business & Industry
          • Biotechnology & Bioengineering
          • Computers & Internet
          • Energy & Resources
          • Engineering
          • Medical Technology
          • Pharmaceuticals
          • Transportation
          • ... more topics
          Education & Learning
          • Animal Learning & Intelligence
          • Creativity
          • Educational Psychology
          • Educational Technology
          • Infant & Preschool Learning
          • Learning Disorders
          • STEM Education
          • ... more topics
      • Quirky
        • Top News
        • Human Quirks
        • Odd Creatures
        • Bizarre Things
        • Weird World
      Free Subscriptions

      Get the latest science news with ScienceDaily's free email newsletters, updated daily and weekly. Or view hourly updated newsfeeds in your RSS reader:

      • Email Newsletters
      • RSS Feeds
      Follow Us

      Keep up to date with the latest news from ScienceDaily via social networks:

      • Facebook
      • Twitter
      • LinkedIn
      Have Feedback?

      Tell us what you think of ScienceDaily -- we welcome both positive and negative comments. Have any problems using the site? Questions?

      • Leave Feedback
      • Contact Us
      About This Site  |  Staff  |  Reviews  |  Contribute  |  Advertise  |  Privacy Policy  |  Editorial Policy  |  Terms of Use
      Copyright 2020 ScienceDaily or by other parties, where indicated. All rights controlled by their respective owners.
      Content on this website is for information only. It is not intended to provide medical or other professional advice.
      Views expressed here do not necessarily reflect those of ScienceDaily, its staff, its contributors, or its partners.
      Financial support for ScienceDaily comes from advertisements and referral programs, where indicated.
      — CCPA: Do Not Sell My Information — — GDPR: Privacy Settings —
      118论坛 118网址之家